This is where sexy comes to die. Not joking - I would even skip the primer so that by the end of the day you get a slight glossy creased effect. These earthy tones are possibly the easiest eye in the universe. All you need is a little brown liner smudged into the lash lines, a healthy helping of mascara and you're set. This is the perfect time to embrace your dark pigmented eyelids as it just adds to the overall look, almost as if you've taken five extra steps.
So beauty guru or not - I urge you to try this type of one eyeshadow look, doesn't have to be these particular shadows, even a dark bronzer will do the trick, just have it packed on the lid and blended into nothingness by the crease/brow bone.
Both Bobbi's and MAC's version have good smooth pigmentation, Bobbi's being a touch smoother but nothing to be angry about. But you do get about 1g more product from MAC against Bobbi's standard 2.5g
What's your definition of sexy?